Calorie Reduction May Trump Fasting for Weight Loss


Although many experts have promoted intermittent fasting as an efficient weight loss strategy, a new study recently published in the Journal of the American Heart Association indicates that time—even extended time—between meals has little or no effect on weight loss. The study found that efficient weight loss was tied much more to basic caloric reduction. The takeaway for dieters is to eat less, not less often.



The six-year study followed the eating habits and diets of 550 people. It found that timing—from first to last meal, or from last meal, through sleep duration, to the day’s first meal—did not significantly impact weight change. 


More importantly, researchers found that individual meals that contained 500 to 1,000 calories were significantly more likely to lead to weight increase, than meals of less than 500 calories. This information indicates possible strategies to achieve and maintain healthy weight.


Eating for Weight Loss

The study’s conclusions suggest some surprising changes in accepted weight maintenance wisdom.


  • Intermittent Irrelevance. Intermittent fasting (time between food intake, lasting between 8 and 24 hours) has shown to offer many health benefits, including boosting immune-system function, improving mental clarity, and moderating blood sugar and heart rate. This new study, however, shows that the practice is unlikely to lead to weight loss—a benefit previously assumed by many health and wellness professionals.


  • Lower calories … daily and per meal. Although we tend to think of restricting daily calories (the national average is a bloated 2,000 for women and 2,500 for men), the study found that restricting caloric counts for individual meals was even more effective. To summarize the findings, better to eat meals under 500 calories, even if you eat more of them each day.


  • The Missing Factor. One issue not addressed in the study is nutrient density. A meal of 490 calories of packaged potato chips would meet the calorie criteria, but obviously, a 490-calorie multi-vegetable salad would be a wiser and much healthier choice. The issue not specifically addressed in the study is nutrient-dense calories versus empty calories. Obviously, reducing calories but while still maintaining an unhealthy diet of processed foods with high amounts of trans fats, sugars, or additives is not going to lead to a good health outcome even if it leads to short-term weight loss.


You can find more information about the study, and about diet as it relates to health (heart and otherwise) on the American Heart Association’s website. For other healthy weight-loss strategies, check out our recent post, Fruitful Weight Loss


Share some love if you like this post!

8290cookie-checkCalorie Reduction May Trump Fasting for Weight Loss

Related Articles

Secrets to Better Sleep

Because we assume that it happens automatically, we tend to tolerate poor sleep. That’s a huge mistake because high-quality sleep may be the golden key that unlocks whole-life health. The opposite is also

Read More »

The Eye-Health Guide to Sunglasses

Basking in the sun is one of the great joys of summer. However, indulge your inner sun worshipper without wearing sunglasses and you may wind up regretting it. Just like your skin, your

Read More »

The DASH Eating Plan

The DASH diet is a well-thought-out nutritional approach to combatting hypertension. The diet provides other health benefits as well. An abbreviation of Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension, the DASH diet was created by

Read More »

Natural Ways to Manage Hypertension

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) estimates that 47 percent of adults in the U.S. suffer from hypertension—more commonly known as high blood pressure—which is defined as readings of more than

Read More »

Combatting Imposter Syndrome

“Fake it ‘till you make it,” is a trite and common saying in modern American culture, but that notion is the source of a great deal of anxiety, angst, and even depression. According

Read More »

More Exercise, Longer Life

The beneficial role exercise plays in both physical and mental health has long been established through vast reams of research. Studies continue to look at the ideal balance of intensity and duration, the

Read More »